Skip to main content

New Jersey Wants Stimulus and Cost Cutting

Tuesday, Feb. 10, 2009

Residents more confident in Obama than Corzine

New Jerseyans are confident in President Obama’s ability to deal with the current financial crisis and most back his stimulus proposal, although they are uncertain of its impact.  The latest Monmouth University/Gannett New Jersey Poll finds a different story at the state level, though.  Garden State residents express less confidence in their governor than their president, few say the state is doing enough to control costs, and many prefer laying off state workers to deferring current pension obligations.

The vast majority (78%) of New Jerseyans feel their state government is not doing enough to control costs during the current economic downturn.  Only 13% say Trenton is keeping costs under control.  Local governments and school districts fare better by comparison.  About 4-in-10 state residents (40%) say their local municipal government is doing enough to control costs (50% say it is not), and a similar number say the same about their local school district (39% is doing enough to 42% is not).

Governor Jon Corzine has proposed allowing local governments to defer some of their pension obligations to make up for reductions in state aid.  The governor has also said that layoffs may be necessary if the state employee unions do not accept a wage freeze.  Critics have already called for state worker layoffs in order to avoid creating more debt.  When asked to choose between these options, slightly more New Jersey residents prefer laying off state government workers in order to cut costs (44%) than putting off current pension payments and increasing future state debt in order to maintain the current level of government services (34%).  Another 15% reject this tradeoff and 8% have no opinion.

Only Republicans are clearly in favor of layoffs – 52% support this option versus 32% who would defer pension payments to maintain services.  Independents tend to prefer the layoffs (42%) to pension deferrals (29%), although 21% reject this as a necessary tradeoff.  The governor’s fellow Democrats are divided – 39% favor layoffs to 43% who prefer pension deferrals.

“Jon Corzine is in a thorny situation.  Ideally, these decisions would be based purely on the merits, but it’s hard to ignore the political ramifications in an election year.  The governor can’t upset his base, but he must also build his standing among independents,” said Patrick Murray, director of the Monmouth University Polling Institute.

The governor laid out some specific plans to deal with the crisis in a speech to the legislature in October and again in his State of the State address last month.  Just 32% of New Jerseyans say they have heard about the governor’s plan to help New Jersey deal with the financial crisis.  Among those who are aware of his ideas, only 32% say the proposals will make things better for New Jersey families.  Another 41% say the governor’s proposals will make no difference and 21% say his plan will make things worse for New Jersey families.

Overall, confidence in the state government’s ability to deal with the financial crisis is lukewarm.  Just under half of New Jersey residents are either very (9%) or somewhat (39%) confident in Governor Corzine’s ability to handle the current situation.  A similar number are generally confident – 5% very and 42% somewhat – in the state legislature.  Confidence in the governor on this issue has slipped by about 6 points since October 2008, while the legislature’s rating is unchanged.

By comparison, fully 3-in-4 New Jerseyans say they are either very (40%) or somewhat (34%) confident in President Barack Obama’s ability to handle the current financial crisis.  This represents a slight increase in the confidence that was expressed in the then-candidate in an October 2008 poll.  Currently, 54% of Republicans and 65% of independents join 94% of Democrats in expressing at least some confidence in the new president’s ability to handle the situation.  The poll also found that 55% of Garden State residents are generally confident in Congress’ ability to deal with the economy, although only 1-in-10 (10%) say they are very confident.

“President Obama’s leadership on the crisis is generating confidence, even though New Jerseyans are uncertain whether his stimulus package will really put the economy back on track,” said Murray.

Nearly two-thirds (64%) of the New Jersey public agree that some sort of economic stimulus package is necessary to improve the current state of the economy.  A somewhat smaller majority (55%) approve of the president’s $800+ billion stimulus proposal that includes tax cuts, aid to states, and spending on several infrastructure projects.  Only 24% disapprove of the plan and another 21% say they do not know enough about it to form an opinion.  Predictably, a large number of Democrats (73%) approve of the proposal.  Nearly half (49%) of independents also approve, while Republicans are divided – 37% approve to 43% disapprove.

Overall, about 1-in-3 (31%) New Jerseyans feel that the current stimulus bill will have a major impact on improving the economy if enacted and another 45% say that any impact will be minor.  Only 15% say that the plan will have no impact at all and 9% have no opinion.  Expectations are mixed even among those who support the president’s proposal – 46% of those who approve of the plan say the economic impact will be major, while a similar 47% say it will probably be minor.

The poll also found that Garden State residents continue to be more somewhat optimistic about their own personal finances than they are about the nation’s.  Specifically, 51% feel optimistic about their family’s financial situation over the next 12 months, while 44% are pessimistic.  By comparison, fewer New Jerseyans – 37% – feel optimistic about the state of the national economy in the coming year, whereas 61% are pessimistic.  These results are basically unchanged from the October 2008 poll.

The Monmouth University/Gannett New Jersey Poll was conducted by telephone with 803 New Jersey adults February 2-8, 2009.  This sample has a margin of error of

+ 3.5 percent.  The poll was conducted by the Monmouth University Polling Institute and originally published by the Gannett New Jersey newspaper group (Asbury Park Press, Courier-Post, Courier News, Daily Journal, Daily Record, and Home News Tribune).

DATA TABLES

The questions referred to in this release are as follows:

(* Some columns may not add to 100% due to rounding.)

[QUESTIONS 1 AND 2 WERE ROTATED]

1. Thinking about the next 12 months, would you say you feel optimistic or pessimistic about your own family’s financial situation?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Optimistic51%50%55%48%48%54%49%51%
Pessimistic44%45%42%45%46%42%45%46%
(VOL) Don’t know5%4%3%6%6%4%6%3%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

2. Thinking about the next 12 months, would you say you feel optimistic or pessimistic about the state of the national economy?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Optimistic37%36%46%27%32%43%33%33%
Pessimistic61%62%51%70%66%55%61%67%
(VOL) Don’t know3%2%3%3%2%2%6%0%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

TRENDS:
Registered voters only

Family’s financial situation

State of national economy

Feb.
2009

Oct.
2008
Feb.
2009

Oct.
2008

Optimistic50%49%36%34%
Pessimistic45%42%62%59%
(VOL) Don’t know4%9%2%7%
Unwtd N

721

900721

900

3. How confident are you in the ability of each of the following to handle the current financial crisis: very confident, somewhat confident, not very confident, or not confident at all?   [ITEMS WERE ROTATED]

Barack Obama

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Very confident40%39%63%27%20%51%41%27%
Somewhat confident34%35%31%38%34%30%35%43%
Not very confident9%10%2%13%17%6%8%12%
Not at all confident12%12%3%15%23%10%11%15%
(VOL) Don’t know5%4%2%7%6%4%5%3%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

The U.S. Congress

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Very confident10%11%17%4%9%14%8%7%
Somewhat confident45%42%60%37%34%48%49%40%
Not very confident24%26%15%27%32%22%23%29%
Not at all confident19%19%8%27%24%16%17%23%
(VOL) Don’t know2%2%0%4%1%1%3%2%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

Jon Corzine

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Very confident9%10%14%5%4%14%7%7%
Somewhat confident39%37%50%36%27%37%45%35%
Not very confident25%26%20%29%32%23%23%30%
Not at all confident23%24%14%27%32%23%23%26%
(VOL) Don’t know3%2%1%3%4%3%2%1%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

The New Jersey state legislature

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Very confident5%5%5%1%5%9%4%3%
Somewhat confident42%41%55%36%31%40%44%40%
Not very confident26%27%24%27%31%28%23%27%
Not at all confident21%22%9%31%27%18%20%29%
(VOL) Don’t know6%5%6%5%6%5%9%2%
Unwtd N803721261309178199260225
TRENDS:
Registered voters only

Barack Obama

U.S. CongressJon Corzinetd>

 

NJ state legislature

Feb.
2009

Oct.
2008
Feb.
2009
Oct.
2008
Feb.
2009
Oct.
2008
Feb.
2009

Oct.
2008

Very confident39%35%11%7%10%14%5%7%
Somewhat confident35%33%42%44%37%39%41%39%
Not very confident10%12%26%24%26%17%27%20%
Not at all confident12%15%19%19%24%24%22%21%
(VOL) Don’t know4%5%2%6%2%7%5%13%
Unwtd N

721

900721900721900721

900

4. Do you think that an economic stimulus package is necessary to improve the current state of the economy, or not?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Is necessary64%64%80%55%54%62%66%66%
Is NOT  necessary27%28%13%37%36%28%25%30%
(VOL) Don’t know9%8%7%8%10%10%9%5%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

5. President Obama has proposed a more than 800 billion dollar plan that would include tax cuts, aid to states, and spending on several infrastructure projects. Do you approve or disapprove of this plan? If you do not know enough about this to have an opinion, please just say so.

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Approve55%55%73%49%37%60%57%53%
Disapprove24%24%4%33%43%18%22%32%
(VOL) Depends3%4%3%4%4%3%3%3%
No opinion/don’t know18%17%20%14%16%19%18%12%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

6. Do you think this plan will have a major impact, minor impact, or no impact in improving the economy?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Major impact31%30%50%20%18%35%30%26%
Minor impact45%45%40%49%49%43%51%47%
No impact15%16%3%23%22%13%13%18%
(VOL) Don’t know9%9%7%8%10%9%6%9%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

7. Have you read or heard anything about Governor Corzine’s plan to help New Jersey deal with the financial crisis?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Yes32%34%29%37%30%26%31%41%
No67%65%70%63%70%74%68%58%
(VOL) Don’t know1%1%1%1%1%0%1%1%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

 [The following question was asked only of those who said “Yes” to Q7, moe= ± 5.8%]

8. Do you think his plan will make things better or worse for New Jersey families, or will it make no difference?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Better32%30%53%22%16%37%34%28%
Worse21%20%9%25%36%30%18%21%
No difference41%44%28%48%47%30%42%47%
(VOL) Don’t know6%6%9%5%1%3%6%4%
Unwtd N

288

27186119625294

103

9. Which of the following would you favor more: laying off state government workers in order to cut costs – OR- putting off current pension payments and increasing future state debt in order to maintain the current level of government services? [RESPONSE OPTIONS WERE ROTATED]

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

Laying off state workers44%45%39%42%52%34%44%56%
Putting off pension payments34%32%43%29%32%41%32%29%
(VOL) Neither15%15%13%21%6%18%13%12%
(VOL) Don’t know8%8%6%8%9%8%11%2%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260225

10. Do you think the state government in Trenton IS or IS NOT doing enough to control costs during this time?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

IS doing enough13%12%17%11%9%18%10%14%
IS NOT doing enough78%79%75%79%86%73%80%81%
(VOL) Don’t know9%9%9%10%6%9%11%6%
Unwtd N

803

721261309178199260

225

[Question 11 was asked of a random half-sample: moe= ± 4.9%]

11. Do you think your local municipal government IS or IS NOT doing enough to control costs during this time?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

IS doing enough40%39%47%38%34%35%45%38%
IS NOT doing enough50%51%45%53%61%52%47%58%
(VOL) Don’t know9%10%8%9%5%13%8%4%
Unwtd N

401

36313115787101121

124

[Question 12 was asked of a random half-sample: moe= ± 4.9%]

12. Do you think your local school district IS or IS NOT doing enough to control costs during this time?

 

TOTAL

Registered
Voters
PARTY ID

INCOME

 

Dem

IndRep<$50K$50-100K

>$100K

IS doing enough39%38%46%38%29%38%33%48%
IS NOT doing enough42%42%39%45%43%43%44%39%
(VOL) Don’t know20%20%15%18%28%19%22%12%
Unwtd N

402

3581301529198139

101

The Monmouth University/Gannett New Jersey Poll was conducted and analyzed by the Monmouth University Polling Institute research staff.  The telephone interviews were collected by Braun Research on February 2-8, 2009 with a statewide random sample of 803 New Jersey adults. For results based on this voter sample, one can say with 95% confidence that the error attributable to sampling has a maximum margin of plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.  Sampling error increases as the sample size decreases, so statements based on various population subgroups, such as separate figures reported by gender or party identification, are subject to more error than are statements based on the total sample.  In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls.

It is the Monmouth University Polling Institute’s policy to conduct surveys of all adult New Jersey residents, including voters and non-voters, on issues which affect the state.  Specific voter surveys are conducted when appropriate during election cycles.

Click on pdf file link below for full methodology and results by key demographic groups.

Download this Poll Report with crosstabs