Skip to main content
Monmouth University Polling Institute

Young Catches Up to Bayh for Senate; Trump Widens Lead for President

Monday, October 31, 2016

Democrat stays ahead in governor’s race

West Long Branch, NJ  - It no longer looks like Democrats can count on Indiana for an easy "plus one" in their bid to take control of the U.S. Senate, according to the latest Monmouth University Poll . Republican Todd Young has erased former senator Evan Bayh's early advantage to pull into a tie for Senate.  Young's campaign gets an assist from the top of the ticket where Donald Trump now holds an 11 point lead over Hillary Clinton for president.  Indiana Democrats can take some comfort from the governor's race, though, where John Gregg is ahead of Eric Holcomb by 6 points.

Among Indiana voters who are likely to cast ballots in November's presidential election or who have already voted early, 50% currently support Trump and 39% back Clinton while another 4% intend to vote for Libertarian Gary Johnson.  The current margin is larger than the 4 point lead Trump held two weeks ago (45% to 41%) and matches the 11 point lead he held in August (47% to 36%).

Trump is ahead among voters without a four-year college degree (54% to 34%) as well as college graduates (46% to 43%).  His non-college edge is similar to prior polls - 53% to 33% in mid-October and 54% to 33% in August.  However, he has turned around a prior deficit among college graduates from 36% to 50% for Clinton in mid-October and 39% to 40% for Clinton in August.

Trump continues to hold a wide lead among men - 54% to 35%, compared with a similar 52% to 34% earlier this month and 51% to 29% in August.  He narrowly leads among women as well, by 47% to 42%, where he had trailed in mid-October (38% Trump to 47% Clinton) and was practically tied in August (44% Trump to 43% Clinton).

The poll was conducted from Thursday through Sunday, but voters interviewed after news broke on Friday about the FBI investigating new emails during Clinton's tenure as Secretary of State were asked about the impact of that news.  A total of 4% of Indiana voters say this news caused them to change their mind about which candidate they would support.  Another 85% said these latest developments ultimately has had no impact on their vote and 9% are unaware of the news.

"Earlier this month it looked like Clinton could potentially make a play for Indiana, but that opportunity has faded.  While the email news does not play a decisive role in the presidential contest, a couple of points on the margins could be having a critical impact on tight down-ballot races," said Patrick Murray, director of the independent Monmouth University Polling Institute.

Turning to the contest to succeed retiring Republican U.S. Senator Dan Coats, former senator Evan Bayh and Congressman Todd Young are tied at 45% for Bayh and 45% for Young.  Libertarian Lucy Brenton garners 4% of the vote.  Bayh had held a steady 6 to 7 point lead in prior Monmouth polls - 48% to 42% in mid-October and 48% to 41% in August.

"Attacks on Bayh's out of state activities have certainly led to this shift, but renewed strength at the top of the ticket is providing a crucial assist for Young," said Murray.

Clinton voters are more likely to stick with the Democrat in the U.S. Senate race than Trump voters are to back the Republican.  Fully 90% of Clinton voters say they will support Bayh - basically unchanged from 87% in mid-October - while only 79% of Trump voters will back Young - similar to 74% earlier this month.

The poll finds that negative ratings of both candidates have crept up in the past two weeks, with Bayh feeling the bigger net negative effect.  Currently, 38% of Indiana voters have a favorable opinion of Bayh and 32% hold an unfavorable view.  He had a somewhat better 40% favorable to 26% unfavorable rating in mid-October and an even better 46% favorable to 19% unfavorable rating in August.

Young gets a 30% favorable to 24% unfavorable rating from the state's voters.  This compares with a 27% favorable to 19% unfavorable rating in mid-October and a 29% favorable to 15% unfavorable rating in August.

The Monmouth University Poll also finds a shift in the race to succeed Pence as governor, but the Democrat still holds the lead.  Former state legislator and 2012 gubernatorial nominee John Gregg is ahead of Lt. Gov. Eric Holcomb by a 48% to 42% margin.  Another 4% support Libertarian Rex Bell.  Gregg held a larger 50% to 38% lead in mid-October while the race was virtually tied in August at 42% for Holcomb and 41% for Gregg.

In other poll results on the presidential race, 35% of Indiana voters have a favorable view of Trump and 51% hold an unfavorable opinion of him.  While these numbers are nothing to brag about, they are nominally better than his prior Hoosier State rating of 31% favorable to 58% unfavorable in mid-October and 33% favorable to 54% unfavorable in August.

Clinton receives an even worse 27% favorable to 63% unfavorable rating, compared with her 30% favorable to 59% unfavorable rating in mid-October and her 28% favorable to 62% unfavorable rating in August.

Indiana's current governor, GOP vice presidential nominee Mike Pence, has seen a slight uptick in his state job approval rating since earlier this month.  He currently earns a 52% approve to 43% disapprove rating for his performance as governor, compared with 47% approve to 44% disapprove two weeks ago.  He had somewhat better ratings in August, after he accepted his party's nomination to the national ticket, of 54% approve to 35% disapprove.

The Monmouth University Poll  was conducted by telephone from October 27 to 30, 2016 with 402 Indiana residents likely to vote in the November election.  This sample has a margin of error of ± 4.9 percent.  The poll was conducted by the Monmouth University Polling Institute in West Long Branch, NJ.


QUESTIONS AND RESULTS                                                               

(* Some columns may not add to 100% due to rounding.)         

1/2.   If the election for President was today, would you vote for Donald Trump the Republican, Hillary Clinton the Democrat, or Gary Johnson the Libertarian? [ IF UNDECIDED: If you had to vote for one of the following candidates at this moment, who do you lean toward - Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton?] [ NAMES WERE ROTATED ]

50%  Donald Trump

39%     Hillary Clinton

  4%     Gary Johnson

  2%     (VOL) Other candidate

  5%     (VOL) Undecided

3.      If the election for U.S. Senate was today, would you vote for Todd Young the Republican, Evan Bayh the Democrat, or Lucy Brenton the Libertarian?  [ IF UNDECIDED: If you had to vote for one of the following candidates at this moment, who do you lean toward - Todd Young or Evan Bayh?]   [ NAMES WERE ROTATED ]

45%     Todd Young

45%     Evan Bayh

  4%     Lucy Brenton

  5%     (VOL) Undecided

4.      If the election for Governor was today, would you vote for Eric Holcomb the Republican, John Gregg the Democrat, or Rex Bell the Libertarian?  [ IF UNDECIDED: If you had to vote for one of the following candidates at this moment, who do you lean toward - Eric Holcomb or John Gregg?]    [ NAMES WERE ROTATED ]

42%     Eric Holcomb

48%     John Gregg

  4%     Rex Bell

  0%     (VOL) Other candidate

  5%     (VOL) Undecided

Regardless of who you may support…


5.      Is your general impression of Donald Trump favorable or unfavorable, or do you have no opinion of him?  

35%     Favorable

51%     Unfavorable

14%     No opinion

6.      Is your general impression of Hillary Clinton favorable or unfavorable, or do you have no opinion of her?  

27%     Favorable

63%     Unfavorable

10%     No opinion


7.      Is your general impression of Todd Young favorable or unfavorable, or do you have no opinion of him?  

30%     Favorable

24%     Unfavorable

45%     No opinion

8.      Is your general impression of Evan Bayh favorable or unfavorable, or do you have no opinion of him?  

38%     Favorable

32%     Unfavorable

29%     No opinion

9.      Do you approve or disapprove of the job Mike Pence is doing as governor?

52%     Approve

43%     Disapprove

  5%     (VOL) No opinion

[ NOTE: Questions 10/11 were asked in interviews conducted Fri-Sun: n=258; moe ± 6.1 ]

10.    Have you read or heard about Friday's news that the FBI is now looking into newly discovered emails from Hillary Clinton's time as Secretary of State, or have you not heard about this recent news? 

91%     Yes, heard

  9%     Not heard

11.    Has this recent news changed your mind about who you will vote for in the presidential election, or has it not really changed your vote choice?

4%     Changed mind about vote

85%     Not changed vote choice

  2%     (VOL) Don't know

  9%     Not heard


The Monmouth University Poll  was sponsored and conducted by the Monmouth University Polling Institute from October 27 to 30, 2016 with a random sample of 402 likely Indiana voters.  Interviews were conducted by a live caller in English, including 352 drawn from a list of registered voters (200 landline / 152 cell phone) and a random digit dial supplement of 50 cell phone interviews.  Monmouth is responsible for all aspects of the survey design, data weighting and analysis. The final sample is weighted for age, gender, race and voting history based on voter list and U.S. Census information.  Data collection support provided by Braun Research (field), Aristotle (voter list sample), and SSI (RDD sample).  For results based on this sample, one can say with 95% confidence that the error attributable to sampling has a maximum margin of plus or minus 4.9 percentage points (unadjusted for sample design).  Sampling error can be larger for sub-groups (see table below).  In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls.

Click on pdf file link below for full methodology and results by key demographic groups.  

Download this Poll Report with all tables

Get Poll Reports in Your Inbox

If you would like to join our mailing list and receive the latest poll results the day they are released, please enter your contact information in the fields below.

Would you like to submit a question or comment?


Any Questions?

Thank You!

Your email has been submitted to our mailing list. You will receive an email to receive future polls the day they are released.

- Monmouth University Polling Institute