Monmouth University

Center for the Arts

Shadow Lawn Series

The Fantasticks

The longest-running show in Off Broadway history, the 1960 musical by the songwriting team of Harvey Schmidt and Tom Jones played for more than four decades and over 17,000 performances at the intimate Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village – winning a special Tony Award.

The Fantasticks is a funny and romantic musical about a boy, a girl, and their two fathers who try to keep them apart. The narrator, El Gallo, asks the audience to use their imagination and follow him into a world of moonlight and magic. The boy and the girl fall in love, grow apart and finally find their way back to each other after realizing the truth in El Gallo’s words that, “without a hurt, the heart is hollow.” (source MTI website)


For this summer-season production of a history-making landmark musical, producer Sheri Anderson and director Michael Perreca have made a direct connection to the show’s rich history, by casting two veterans of the show’s legendary New York run. Starring as El Gallo, the bandit-for-hire who serves as the show’s narrator, is David Edwards, who played the role for more than 500 performances at Sullivan Street, and who was featured in the 2003 documentary Try to Remember: The Fantasticks. Fellow Off Broadway cast member J.C. Hoyt returns to the role of Henry, the Old Actor who assists the bandit in an elaborate ruse designed to unite the young neighbors Matt (“The Boy”) and Luisa (“The Girl”).


Appearing respectively as Matt and Luisa are Keenan Buckley and Sarah Beth Andrews, with Brett Lowell and Felipe Gorostiza as the “feuding” fathers Bellamy and Hucklebee. The cast is completed by a pair of alumni from Monmouth’s Department of Music and Theater Arts, Brandon M. Wiener (Mortimer) and Evan Kudish (The Mute), with those roles understudied by Monmouth students Christian Lombino and Erin Clemente.


Featuring choreography by Janine Molinari and musical direction by Michael Gilch, The Fantasticks is a timeless tale of both romance and reality, told with a bracing humor and a sense of stage magic that never goes out of style.

Box Office: 732.263.6889

Jun21, 2018

May24, 2020

6/21 at 8 PM

5/31 at 12 AM

7/18 at 8 PM

7/24 at 7 PM

7/29 at 9 AM

7/29 at 7 PM

7/31 at 7 PM

8/7 at 7 PM

8/10 at 8 PM

8/14 at 7 PM

9/3 at 12 AM

9/3 at 12 AM

9/10 at 8 PM

9/17 at 4:30 PM

9/17 at 7:30 PM

9/19 at 7:30 PM

9/20 at 8 AM

9/23 at 12 AM

9/23 at 7:30 PM

9/25 at 7:30 PM

9/26 at 7:30 PM

9/28 at 8 PM

10/4 at 8 PM

10/10 at 7:30 PM

10/11 at 8 PM

10/12 at 1 PM

10/15 at 7:30 PM

10/16 at 4:30 PM

10/18 at 8 PM

10/20 at 1 PM

10/21 at 7:30 PM

10/22 at 10:30 AM

10/24 at 7:30 PM

10/26 at 1 PM

10/27 at 1 PM

11/2 at 8 PM

11/3 at 1 PM

11/4 at 4:30 PM

11/5 at 7:30 PM

11/9 at 1 PM

11/15 at 8 PM

11/15 at 8 PM

11/16 at 8 PM

11/18 at 4:30 PM

11/18 at 7:30 PM

11/21 at 7:30 PM

11/22 at 7:30 PM

11/23 at 1 PM

11/24 at 1 PM

12/3 at 10 AM

12/5 at 7:30 PM

12/6 at 7 PM

12/6 at 8 PM

12/8 at 1 PM

12/10 at 7:30 PM

12/12 at 7:30 PM

12/15 at 1 PM

1/11 at 1 PM

1/21 at 12 AM

1/21 at 8 AM

1/26 at 1 PM

1/28 at 7:30 PM

1/28 at 7:30 PM

1/30 at 7:30 PM

2/1 at 1 PM

2/8 at 8 PM

2/9 at 1 PM

2/10 at 10:30 AM

2/13 at 7:30 PM

2/18 at 7:30 PM

2/21 at 7:30 PM

2/23 at 1 PM

2/26 at 7:30 PM

2/27 at 10 AM

2/27 at 12 PM

2/28 at 8 PM

2/29 at 1 PM

3/2 at 6 PM

3/4 at 8 PM

3/7 at 8 PM

3/8 at 1 PM

3/10 at 7:30 PM

3/14 at 1 PM

3/22 at 1 PM

3/24 at 7:30 PM

3/26 at 10 AM

3/27 at 12 AM

3/28 at 8 PM

3/28 at 8 PM

3/30 at 12 AM

4/5 at 1 PM

4/7 at 4:30 PM

4/10 at 12 AM

4/10 at 8 PM

4/11 at 1 PM

4/13 at 10:30 AM

4/14 at 7:30 PM

4/18 at 7 PM

4/19 at 1 PM

4/23 at 7:30 PM

4/23 at 7:30 PM

4/24 at 7 PM

4/26 at 12 AM

4/26 at 1 PM

5/5 at 7:30 PM

5/7 at 10 AM

5/9 at 1 PM

5/17 at 1 PM

5/24 at 1 PM

$30 (general); $20 (seniors/alumni/employees); $10 (children/students)

Buy Tickets

Related Events

Vincent DiMattio: DreamPaths and Napkin Drawings

May 31 Jul 26

Pollak Gallery

Gallery Exhibitions

Vincent DiMattio: DreamPaths and Napkin Drawings

An exhibit of drawings on napkins and new works by Vincent DiMattio. DiMattio earned his MFA from Southern Illinois University and his BFA from Massachusetts College of Art. He joined Monmouth University’s faculty in 1968 where he served as the department chair for 13 years and as gallery director for more than 20 years. He has shown his work internationally in Madrid, Spain; San Juan, Puerto Rico and Pueblo, Mexico. He has also exhibited throughout the United States, and at both the Newark and Trenton Museums.

Free Event

Summer Encore Series: Hamlet
Broadcast in HD

Jul 19 2019

7 PM
Pollak Theatre

Live Theatre Broadcasts in HD

National Theatre: Broadcast in HD

Summer Encore Series: Hamlet

Benedict Cumberbatch (BBC’s Sherlock, Doctor Strange) plays the title role of Shakespeare’s great tragedy. Now seen by over 900,000 people worldwide, the original broadcast returns to cinemas to mark National Theatre Live’s 10th birthday. As a country arms itself for war, a family tears itself apart. Forced to avenge his father’s death but paralysed by the task ahead, Hamlet rages against the impossibility of his predicament, threatening both his sanity and the security of the state.

Past Event

Summer Encore Series: La Boheme
Broadcast in HD

Jul 24

7 PM
Pollak Theatre

The Metropolitan Opera: Live in HD

Summer Encore Series: La Boheme

Franco Zeffirelli’s picturesque staging, an audience favorite for more than 30 years, features a winning young cast, including soprano Kristine Opolais and tenor Vittorio Grigolo as the lovers Mimì and Rodolfo. Stefano Ranzani conducts.

Buy Tickets

Van Gogh: Of Wheat Fields and Clouded Skies – Encore Screening

Jul 29

7 PM
Pollak Theatre

Great Art on Screen

Van Gogh: Of Wheat Fields and Clouded Skies – Encore Screening

Take a fresh look at Van Gogh through the legacy of the greatest private collector of the Dutch artist’s work: Helene Kröller-Müller (1869-1939), one of the first to recognize the genius of Van Gogh. In the early 20th century, Kröller-Müller amassed nearly 300 of Van Gogh’s paintings and drawings now housed at her namesake museum in Holland. The Basilica Palladina exhibition in Vicenza, “Amid Wheat Fields and Clouded Skies,” with 40 paintings and 85 drawings on loan from the Kröller-Müller Museum, lends the basis of this program, revealing Van Gogh’s art and his genius, while allowing audiences to understand the importance of drawing as part of his craft.

Buy Tickets

Small Island
Broadcast in HD

Jul 31

7 PM
Pollak Theatre

National Theatre: Broadcast in HD

Small Island

Andrea Levy’s Orange Prize-winning novel Small Island comes to life in an epic new theatre adaptation. Experience the play in cinemas, filmed live on stage as part of National Theatre Live’s 10th birthday. Small Island embarks on a journey from Jamaica to Britain, through the Second World War to 1948 – the year the HMT Empire Windrush docked at Tilbury, England. The play follows three intricately connected stories. Hortense yearns for a new life away from rural Jamaica, Gilbert dreams of becoming a lawyer, and Queenie longs to escape her Lincolnshire roots. Hope and humanity meet stubborn reality as the play traces the tangled history of Jamaica and the UK. A company of 40 actors take to the stage of the National Theatre in London in this timely and moving story.

Buy Tickets

Let’s Keep In Touch!